Can You Actually Prove Marketing's Pipeline Contribution?

You know the drill. Your CEO wants to see what marketing is doing for the pipeline. Sales says your leads are subpar. And you’re stuck in the middle with a CRM that’s supposed to give you answers but feels like a black box. Attribution is one of those politically charged topics in B2B marketing where no one really knows who to trust. Let's break down what’s really happening.

What First-Touch Attribution Actually Measures

First-touch attribution is a method that gives full credit to the first channel someone interacts with. It's simple and easy to understand, but it overstates marketing's contribution because it ignores all the other touches that happened later, often from sales or internal teams, which can be crucial in closing a deal. For example, if a lead clicks on a social media ad initially but then is nurtured by email campaigns and finally contacted by a sales representative, first-touch attribution would credit the social media ad for the entire deal, even though the subsequent touches were equally important in converting the lead into a customer.

In HubSpot, first-touch attribution is likely part of your default setup. However, it's only a starting point and doesn't give a full picture of your marketing efforts' impact. It can be misleading because it oversimplifies the path to conversion, leading to an inaccurate assessment of which channels are most effective in generating revenue.

What Multi-Touch Attribution Shows

Multi-touch attribution is a more sophisticated method that gives credit to all the channels that touched a lead throughout their journey. This approach is more complex than first-touch attribution but still imperfect because it can overvalue early touches and undervalue later ones. For instance, if a lead initially found your company through a blog post but was then converted into a customer through targeted email campaigns and sales follow-ups, multi-touch attribution would distribute credit among these channels, yet the final touches might have played a more critical role in closing the deal than the initial touchpoint.

HubSpot offers multi-touch attribution, but it's not foolproof. The model can get messy with too many touches and might not accurately reflect the true influence of each interaction. This complexity can lead to confusion when trying to determine which marketing activities are driving the most significant impact on your pipeline.

Attribution Blind Spots in HubSpot

Even with a well-configured CRM like HubSpot, there are blind spots that can affect your attribution data:

Offline Touches: Meetings, calls, or events that aren’t recorded in the CRM. For example, if you have an in-person meeting with a potential customer where they express interest but don’t convert until later, this touchpoint isn’t captured in the system, leading to an incomplete picture of the lead’s journey.

Dark Social: Interactions on platforms where referrer data is not available. This includes private messaging on social media platforms or email sharing that doesn't pass along referral information, making it difficult to track the source of the lead accurately.

Late-Stage SDR Sequences: When sales reps take over and generate activity after marketing has already sourced a lead. If an SDR sequence generates significant activity in the late stages of the funnel, these touches can overshadow the initial marketing efforts that brought the lead into your pipeline.

These blind spots can skew your attribution data and make it harder to get a clear picture of marketing’s impact on the pipeline. Addressing these gaps is crucial for understanding the true value of each touchpoint and making informed decisions about future marketing strategies.

What "Good Enough" Attribution Looks Like

For teams of 1-3 marketers, “good enough” means having a simple, actionable model that gives you insights without overwhelming you with data. This approach allows you to make meaningful decisions based on clear and relevant information. To achieve this, start by defining shared pipeline definitions with sales. Agreeing on what counts as a marketing-sourced lead is essential because it ensures both teams are working from the same set of criteria. For instance, if marketing defines a lead as someone who has engaged with your content three times, while sales considers a lead someone who has requested more information, these differing definitions can create confusion and misalignment.

Agreeing on lead stages is another critical step. Both teams should have the same understanding of where leads are in the funnel to ensure consistent tracking and reporting. For example, if marketing moves a lead from "awareness" to "consideration," sales needs to recognize this stage to continue nurturing the lead appropriately.

Weekly revenue reviews are also crucial for discussing what’s working and what isn’t. These meetings provide an opportunity to assess the effectiveness of your current strategies and adjust them as needed. For instance, if you notice that leads sourced from webinars are converting at a higher rate than those from email campaigns, you can shift resources to focus more on webinars.

This doesn’t require complex models or tools. It’s about creating a system that both marketing and sales can trust, ensuring that your efforts are aligned with the company's revenue goals.

The One Conversation Marketers Need to Have with Their CRO

Before diving into attribution, you need to have an honest conversation with your Chief Revenue Officer (CRO). This discussion is crucial for setting realistic expectations and aligning on key objectives. Acknowledge the limitations of attribution models from the start. Be upfront about what they can and cannot do. For example, while attribution can provide insights into which marketing channels are driving conversions, it cannot always pinpoint the exact influence of each touchpoint. It's important to manage expectations so that both parties understand the value and limitations of these models.

Focus on revenue accountability as the goal, not just proving marketing’s contribution. The aim is to ensure everyone is accountable for driving revenue, which requires collaboration between marketing and sales. Discussing goals and metrics is also essential. Align on what success looks like and how you’ll measure it. For instance, if your company's goal is to increase revenue by 20% next quarter, determine the specific metrics that will indicate progress towards this target.

This conversation sets the stage for a more productive relationship between marketing and sales, where attribution is just one piece of the puzzle. It fosters a collaborative environment where both teams work together towards shared goals, rather than operating in silos.

Repositioning the Problem

Attribution isn’t the end goal. It’s a means to an end. The real goal is revenue accountability. By focusing on shared goals and metrics, you can build a system that everyone trusts and works towards. This approach ensures that both marketing and sales are aligned and working together to drive revenue growth.

For example, if your company's goal is to increase revenue by 50% over the next year, attribution models can help you understand which channels and campaigns are most effective in driving leads through the funnel. However, it’s important to remember that attribution alone doesn’t guarantee success. It must be paired with actionable insights and strategies that address the specific needs of your business.

By repositioning the problem from simply measuring marketing's contribution to achieving shared revenue goals, you can create a more cohesive and effective approach to driving growth. This involves not just measuring what’s happening but also understanding why certain strategies are working or failing and using this knowledge to make informed decisions about future initiatives.

Want to see where your blind spots are? We run free diagnostics for companies like yours.

Want to see where your CRM is leaking revenue?

We run free 30-minute HubSpot diagnostics. Your portal, on screen, live. You leave with a prioritized fix list, yours to keep whether you hire us or not.